Recruiterbox is now Hire, part of the new Trakstar Trifecta alongside Learn and Perform

Learn more about how the Trakstar platform is revolutionizing talent management through integrated, flexible solutions.

All Blog Articles

The Domino Effect: How One Bad Hire Can Lead to a Cascade of Turnover

In Company Culture — by Noel Diem

Picture this for a second: You’ve hired a new employee you thought would fit your team perfectly. On paper, they have the skills needed to be the perfect candidate. Their personality in the interview seems like it will fit in seamlessly with your company culture.

However, as time passes, it becomes clear that they’re not meeting expectations and causing tension amongst their colleagues. Before you know it, other employees begin quitting due to the toxic work environment created by this one bad hire. 

Sound familiar?

This is known as the domino effect of the wrong hire and can have a devastating impact on any organization. In this blog post, we’ll explore how one bad hire can lead to a cascade of turnover and what steps you can take to prevent it from happening in your workplace.

Let’s dive in!

Introduction: The Domino Effect of Bad Hires

Bad hires can have a domino effect when it comes to turnover rates among your existing employees. Not only does hiring the wrong person lead to increased turnover, but it can also create a ripple effect where good employees decide to leave as well. For some, it might be the catalyst for moving into another job. For others, they may have been unhappy for some time and use your wrong hire as the reason for leaving. You will only know if you run exit interviews – and even then, many people won’t be honest.

In addition, bad hires can negatively impact morale and productivity, creating a toxic work environment. A bad candidate won’t only impact their team – those bad attitudes can work through departments that are only adjacent to the one the wrong hire is in. Including existing employees in conversations around hiring and the recruitment process can help find a good hire instead.

It’s essential to take your time when making hiring decisions and to avoid rushed or careless decisions. It doesn’t matter if you are trying to find the ideal candidate during your executive search or if you are just finding an entry-level qualified candidate. One hiring mistake impacts all of your talent.
If you do make a bad hire, don’t hesitate to correct the mistake – the sooner you do, the less damage will be done. Hiring costs are high, but the costs of making a poor hire are even higher.

How Human Resources Makes Hiring Mistakes

Several bad hiring practices can lead to high turnover rates. One of the most common is hiring someone who is not a good fit for the position or company culture or doesn’t fulfill the job description. This can happen when a company is more focused on filling a position quickly than on finding the right person for the job. The result is that the new hire is not well-suited to the position and is likely to become frustrated and quit.

We suggest writing a good job description that helps you identify the right candidate and gives the potential employee a good idea about what would make them a good fit for your organization.
Another bad hiring practice that can lead to high turnover is hiring someone without properly vetting them. This can happen when a company relies too heavily on resumes and interviews and doesn’t take the time to do a background or reference check. As a result, they may hire someone who has lied about their qualifications or who has a history of job hopping.

Ask references questions that help you determine if the potential hire will be the right fit for your company and current employees.

Yet another bad hiring practice that can contribute to high turnover rates is failing to provide adequate training. When new hires are not given enough information about their job duties or the company’s culture, they are more likely to become overwhelmed and quit.
All of these bad hiring practices can have a domino effect, leading to a cascade of turnover.

Factors Contributing to Poor Performance in the Hiring Process

There are a number of factors that can contribute to poor performance in the hiring process. One of the most common is a lack of understanding of the job requirements. This can lead to applicants being underqualified for the position or to them not having the necessary skills and experience.

Another factor that can contribute to poor performance is a lack of preparation. Many applicants go into an interview without taking the time to research the company or the position they’re applying for. This can lead to them not being able to answer questions about the company or the role, and it can also make them appear uninterested in the position.

A third factor that can impact performance is nerves. Many people get nervous when they’re interviewed for a job, and this can lead to them fumbling over their words or forgetting important information.

Some people simply don’t do well in interviews. This could be because they’re introverted or because they have difficulty communicating their thoughts clearly. Whatever the reason, if someone is not good at interviews, it will likely impact their performance in the hiring process.

Tips for Avoiding Bad Hires

The first step to avoiding bad hires is to clearly understand the job requirements. What skills and experience are required to perform the job successfully? Ensure these criteria are included in the job posting and during the interview process.

Next, take the time to screen candidates thoroughly. In addition to reviewing resumes and conducting interviews, consider using pre-employment assessments to get a better sense of a candidate’s skills and abilities. These assessments can help identify potential red flags that may not be apparent during the interview process.

Trust your gut. If something feels off about a candidate, moving on to someone else is probably best. The last thing you want is to hire someone who turns out to be a poor fit for the job and ends up causing turnover down the line.

Alternatives to Bad Hiring Practices

It’s no secret that bad hiring practices can lead to a host of problems within a company, from high turnover rates to decreased productivity. But what are some alternatives to these bad practices?

One alternative is to focus on talent management. This means identifying the top performers within your company and making sure they are properly groomed for leadership positions. This can help to prevent the domino effect of one bad hire leading to a cascade of turnover.

Another alternative is to invest in pre-employment screening. This can help you to weed out candidates who are not a good fit for your company and save you time and money in the long run.

Make sure you take the time to properly train your employees. This will help them to be more successful in their roles and less likely to leave your company down the line.

Ready to Make Better Hires?

The domino effect of hiring a bad employee can be devastating to an organization. By taking the time to evaluate candidates carefully and ensuring that they are a good fit for the role, companies can avoid making costly mistakes in their hiring process. Furthermore, employers should also focus on creating an environment where employees feel supported and valued so that they remain engaged with the company and contribute positively to its success. Taking these steps will help ensure that your business is able to recruit and retain top talent while avoiding any negative repercussions from making bad hires.

Click here to schedule a demo of Trakstar Hire to learn more.

Trakstar Hire is considered the most user friendly hiring software on the market. If you’re ready to take your recruiting and hiring to the next level, request a Trakstar Hire demo today.

Who is Trakstar?

Trakstar is a multi-product HR software provider helping organizations put the people back in people management. Develop and align your staff through better recruiting and applicant tracking, performance management, and learning management. For a more integrated solution to talent management, check out our website and request a live demonstration today.

© 2024 Trakstar